Friday, April 2, 2010

Spend less or Spend wise?

My company makes software for spend management. But that is not the reason for writing this article. It is a video, which was seen in YouTube a couple of days back.

In that video, people are chosen randomly and are asked what they would do if they get Rs 500. Different people gave different answers. Some wanted to party, some others wanted to use it for things like school fee and books, while a handful of others wanted to just keep it.

What do we do when we have money in hand? Does our mind tell us to keep it and not to spend much or to spend wisely?

The point is - if the people in a country chose to spend less, the income of the country is no way going to increase. One example, which was given as a comment on that video, Suppose I get Rs 500 and I choose to spend it for a hair-cut. I get the value of Rs 500 and the barber is now richer by Rs 500. Now the barber uses that money to buy vegetables. He gets the value for that money and now the shopkeeper in that vegetable shop can use that same money for his children’s education.

So, each time when money passes from one hand to other, one person gets the value of his/her earning and the other person is richer by Rs 500. Each time, country's income increases by Rs 500.

Now, consider the other scenario. I have decided not to spend my 500 rupees. Thus money doesn’t circulate through the barber and shop keeper. Their business is less at the end of the day, which results in less income for the country and poor/no education for the shop keeper’s kids.

The example cited above is the small scale version of what happens in the society. Now the question is whether the money reaches the bottom levels. If the money circulation of only among the rich, the result would be, rich becomes more rich and poor remains poor. The decision of how to spend the money plays an important role.

Another thought. If distribution of wealth is uniform in our society and if every person is as rich as the other one, do you think there would be carpenters, auto rickshaw drivers, tea-shop owners and hotel waiters? As these are low income jobs?

There can be richer or less rich people. It is poverty which needs to be wiped off. It is not the equal distribution of money which is required in this country. It is wise spending. Bear with me if I sounded like an anti communist at any point. If you can’t, feel free to shout back!!!

Disclaimer: The opinion in this article is mine and do not reflect that of my employer. J

Note: Spending Rs 500 for a hair-cut may seem a bit weird. I took it directly from the video comment. Take it for that or replace with something else. ;)

7 comments:

  1. When some one spend Rs.500/-, the person receiving the money makes the income of the NATION to increment by 500.
    Will it not make a loss to the NATION through the person spending the money???

    if it sound stupid, please neglect it ;)...

    :P

    ReplyDelete
  2. No, it is not stupidity, but a general misconception. Actually spending the money is not a loss. Only if the money is spent, the person will be getting the value for that money, Otherwise it will remain only as a paper with Gandhi’s head printed on it.
    Have you thought why RBI simply print a lot of money and distribute it to the people? Especially when there are a lot of poor people in our country? The reason is, it will only decrease the value of money.

    ReplyDelete
  3. then.... when spending money, it will not increase the income too...

    When a barber gets 500/- its just a flow of money, for a service (or product in general).
    I don't think the spending of money will increase something...

    but for sure, the NOT SPEND money is a DEAD money, no one will ever get any GOOD from that. But they always can keep their money, if some one doesn't want to spend it, but not in their HOUSE LOCKERS, but in bank. Even that is their contribution to the national Currency Cycle!!!

    correct me if I'm wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  4. please remove the picture verification from your comment option!!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. if ur money is spent, u get the value of it and someone's income increases.
    but if ur money is stolen, then it is a loss for u even though it is an increase in income for the thief.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really agree with Vivek's words. As he explained the case of hair cut,for e.g the person who receives the rs 500 will get a profit 100 rs. In that case his investment for one haircut is 400 and he is getting 500, 100 rs profit , from there to vegetable shop, the shop keeper also will get some profit, means the value of money gets increases. Good thoughts

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hope Manu got satisfying answer from the other comments. By the way, picture verification do not come every time and i think it cannot be controlled by the user (didn't find an option in the settings). Its for stopping the comments sent through malicious code.

    Thanks to all for the participation

    ReplyDelete